Talk: Stock option
From open-encyclopedia.com - the free encyclopedia.
The article says, in the passive voice,
It is estimated that over-reporting of income by an average of 25% by American corporations was one cause of the Stock Market Downturn of 2002.
.. but I would like to know whose estimate that is, and where the 25% figure comes from, and which companies are being described - is that S&P 500 companies, or NASDAQ companies, or nutty startups, or little 5-person S-corps, or what? Should this read "Companies who over-reported income did so by an average of 25%?".
Stock option repeats much of the general discussion that is in Option and some of both should perhaps be moved to Option (Security) as a better title. Stock Option is un-usefully specific, as there are many types of securities options that have other underlying instruments besides stocks. Taxman 05:04, May 5, 2004 (UTC)
- I agree that there is some overlap. If you choose to merge stock option into option, you should probably be consistant and merge all the specific forms of options (such as interest rate options and swaptions) into the general category as well. But if you think that reasonable articles can be written on the sub-categories, then it would be better to keep them all as seperate articles. If you choose to merge the subcategories into the root options article, make sure that you retain the titles as redirects because these are the terms that people will typically use in a data search. mydogategodshat 15:53, 7 May 2004 (UTC)
- I would strongly urge against merging all those things into one topic, a lot can be said unique to each, even if we haven't quite reached that amount of detail yet. Pete/Pcb21 (talk) 16:26, 7 May 2004 (UTC)
- I agree. mydogategodshat
Stock options can be a separate page
The stock option market is much more organized and liquid than that for other types of options. For instance, there are six separate option exchanges in the U.S., as well as hundreds of companies that specialize in trading these contracts. I think stock options should remain a separate topic so that additional information on the market structure can be explored. (unsigned)
- Yeah, I agree now that I think about it, but then this article should focus only on the unique features of stock options in comparison to the general idea of options. - Taxman 12:51, Jul 23, 2004 (UTC)
In the section on employee options, this article claims: "Main article at Employee stock option", but almost all of that content is replicated here. Would it be acceptable to remove the duplicated content here with "See Employee stock option"? --Jarsyl 01:27, 2004 Sep 30 (UTC)
